| 2024 | Vivienne Paratore |
| 2023 | Meg Amouroux |
| 2022 | Jim McConnell |
| 2021 | Sylvia Ma |
| 2020 | Sylvia Ma |
| 2019 | Monique Manjarrez |
| 2018 | Bruce Roberts |
| 2017 | Vivienne Paratore |
| 2016 | Meg Amouroux |
| 2015 | Dave Nelsen |
| 2014 | Mike Scrutton |
| 2013 | Janet Fischer |
| 2012 | Janet Fischer |
| 2011 | Mary Casas |
| 2010 | Jan Scrutton |
| 2009 | Sylvia Ma |
| 2008 | Sylvia Ma |
| 2007 | Barbara Dabney |
| 2006 | Pegeen Perry |
| 2005 | Brad Hoffman |
| 2004 | Mary Dearborn |
| 2003 | E.J. Hilliard |
| 2002 | E.J. Hilliard |
| 2001 | Lynn Locher |
| 2000 | Lynn Locher |
| 1999 | Janet Fischer |
| 1998-99 | Janet Fischer (Vestry year changed to run on the calendar year) |
| 1997-98 | Charlie Dickinson |
| 1996-97 | Ed Abram |
| 1995-96 | Maggie Shalar |
| 1994-95 | Julie Roberts |
| 1993-94 | Valle Brokes |
| 1992-93 | Pam Rice |
| 1991-92 | Pam Rice |
| 1990-91 | Maggie Shalar |
| 1989-90 | F. Preston (Bud) Spalding (From this point and prior, Vestry Minutes do not name the Sr. Warden) |
| 1988-89 | Roberta “Bobbie” Tomkinson |
| 1987-88 | Ray Hedvall |
| 1986-87 | Nat Bryant |
| 1985-86 | Bud Spalding |
| 1984 -85 | Dick Aston (Vestry year changed to run June-May) |
| 1983 | Lori Hedvall |
| 1982 | Jay Hendee |
| 1981 | Jan Gaynor |
| 1980 | Jan Gaynor |
| 1979 | George Vlastelica |
| 1978 | Roberta “Bobbie” Tomkinson |
| 1977 | David Gaynor |
| 1976 | Edwin L. Bowers |
| 1975 | Elsworth Finlay (Note: Jan. 1975 Annual Meeting is recorded as “27th Annual meeting of the Parish” which means annual meeting records should go back to 1948) |
| 1974 | Richard L. “Dick” Aston |
| 1973 | Ed Abram |
| 1972 | Kenn Taylor |
| 1971 | |
| 1970 | Donald Curley |
| 1969 | Elsworth Finlay |
| 1968 | Don Schaaf/Laurie Davis? |
| 1967 | Dean Widrig |
| 1966 | |
| 1965 | Dean R. Widrig |
| 1964 | James D. McGrew |
| 1963 | James D. McGrew |
| 1962 | Dean Jones |
| 1961 | |
| 1960 | Patrick Kesler |
| 1955 | L.S. Whitaker Jr. |
| 1949 | Mr. Claire Lopez |
| 1948 | John Richard Sutton [The first Sr. Warden after St. James’ attained parish status. The Education Building is named “Sutton Hall” for him.] |
| 1936-1940 | Philip H. Moore |
| 1924-1935 | Hugh E. Mosher |
| 1877 | C.S. Haley |